Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Bananza!

            I found Lalita’s articles on GMOs (genetically modified organisms) to be pretty fascinating. But one in particular struck me more than the others- it is an issue that could end up affecting me in the future. When I think about food sustainability problems in other countries, like golden rice grown in Africa to feed millions of people, I don’t quite feel a personal connection to it since that is a food I rarely encounter. But when I hear that my favorite fruit could soon disappear from grocery stores, it hits home. “We Have No Bananas” is a piece that begins with the history of this delicious fruit.
            I never realized that only one type of banana is sold at most stores. Think about apples: there’s Honey Crisp, Fuji, Red Delicious, Granny Smith, etc. And pears: Green, Red, Asian, White. It never even occurred to me that different types of bananas existed, let alone thousands of them! According to this article, a variety of bananas called Cavendish, which was discovered in southern China in the nineteenth-century, represent ninety-nine percent of all banana exports because of their high yield, thick skin, and large bunches.
          In America, we get almost all of our bananas imported from Latin America. But why not China? Isn’t that where the bananas originally came from? As it turns out, Cavendish bananas are too good to be true. They have been completely wiped out across Asia due to a pestilence called Tropical Race Four (a soil-borne fungus). What scares me the most about this article is that scientists believe this destructive fungus will soon find its way to Central America. What would this mean? Potentially, no more bananas.
           Most babies are fed off of bananas as one of the first foods they are introduced to because they are soft and comforting. Bananas have been a part of my life ever since I can remember. They are nutritious, delicious, and can be baked into dozens of recipes (chocolate chip banana bread anyone??). And this piece reminded me of that. It has a way of drawing the reader in with a compelling story that most Americans would be affected by. It gets people thinking: what can be done to protect these fruits?
          This is where the article relates back to GMOs. Scientists are in the process of developing genetically modified Cavendish bananas that are resistant to Tropical Race Four. If they are successful, then the banana crisis would be over! Or would it…What if these new bananas don’t taste the same as the natural Cavendish. Or what if they cause health risks to humans (digestive problems, cancer). These are the kinds of problems that have arisen over GMOs in the past, and are likely to arise again. So in my mind, the real problem goes way beyond bananas. It goes beyond fruits and vegetables, even beyond food itself. The real questions: What happens when we mess with nature? Is it really possible to eradicate all the obstacles that surround the global resources (like food) needed for human existence? If so, then how?

2 comments:

  1. Hey Jessie!
    I know this isn't a very common issue, but it should be! This problem is not only affecting bananas, but it's affecting the other foods that we eat everyday. Sometimes, it makes me wonder whether or not the food we eat is how it naturally tastes. This is one of those issues where I can understand both sides of the argument. We want to keep things as natural as possible, but at the same time we want to prevent bananas from going extinct. It's quite an interesting debate that should really be emphasized in the science world.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post, Jessie. I like how you build up to your key question at the end, and you also did a nice job of integrating voice into this post.

    By the way, your post reminds me of some of the ideas/questions we explored in "Created Worlds" with "Frankenstein."

    ReplyDelete